[CALL TO ORDER]
[00:00:02]
WOULD YOU PLEASE RISE? DEAR LORD, WE THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS DAY. WE THANK YOU FOR THIS COMMUNITY. WE ASK THAT YOU BLESS THIS COMMUNITY AND KEEP THEM SAFE.
WE ASK THAT YOU TAKE CARE OF OUR FIRST RESPONDERS, KEEP THEM SAFE.
AND THANK YOU FOR THEIR WORK IN KEEPING OUR COMMUNITY SAFE.
TONIGHT, WE ASK THAT YOU HELP ALL OF THIS COUNCIL MAKE DECISIONS ON BEHALF OF ALL OF OUR COMMUNITY.
WE PRAY THAT WE MAKE THESE DECISIONS FOR THE BETTERMENT OF OUR COMMUNITY.
AND THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR ALL THAT YOU DO FOR ALL OF US.
IT'S IN YOUR NAME WE PRAY. AMEN. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.
HONOR THE TEXAS FLAG. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THEE TEXAS.
ONE STATE UNDER GOD, ONE AND INDIVISIBLE. THANK YOU.
SO TONIGHT. WE HAVE ONE PROCLAMATION TO PRESENT.
[Proclamation: July is National Parks and Recreation Month.]
JULY IS NATIONAL PARKS AND RECREATION MONTH, WHERE WE RECOGNIZE PAST AND PRESENT LEADERS AND STAFF FOR THEIR WORK TO ENSURE WE HAVE A TOP RANKED PARK SYSTEM. SO I'D LIKE TO INTRODUCE RON SMITH, PARKS AND REC DIRECTOR HANNAH RUSHING, INTERIM ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF PARKS. GREGG GAGNON, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF RECREATION.SO IT'S MY HONOR TO PRESENT THIS PROCLAMATION.
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES PASSING AN OFFICIAL RESOLUTION IN 2009 IN RECOGNITION OF THE VITAL ROLE PARKS AND RECREATION PLAY IN BUILDING STRONG, HEALTHY AND VIBRANT COMMUNITIES. WHEREAS, THE CITY OF PLANO IS PROUD THAT PLANO PARKS AND RECREATION WAS RANKED NUMBER ONE IN THE GREAT STATE OF TEXAS AND 13TH IN THE UNITED STATES IN THE 2026 TRUST FOR PUBLIC LAND PARKSCORE INDEX, REFLECTING THE CITY'S CONTINUED COMMITMENT TO PROVIDING EXCEPTIONAL PARKS, TRAILS, OPEN SPACES AND RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES FOR RESIDENTS AND VISITORS ALIKE. WHEREAS PARKS AND RECREATION ENHANCES THE QUALITY OF LIFE FOR ALL PLANO RESIDENTS BY PROMOTING PHYSICAL HEALTH, MENTAL WELLNESS, ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP, ECONOMIC VITALITY, COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT, AND ACCESS TO SAFE AND WELCOMING PUBLIC SPACES. PLANO'S EXTENSIVE PARK SERVICES BRINGS NEIGHBORS TOGETHER, FOSTERS CIVIC PRIDE, ENCOURAGES HEALTHY LIFESTYLES, AND STRENGTHENS THE SENSE OF COMMUNITY THAT HAS HELPED MAKE PLANO THE CITY OF EXCELLENCE.
NOW, THEREFORE, I, JOHN MUNS, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF PLANO, TEXAS, DO HEREBY PROCLAIM THE MONTH OF JULY 2026 AS PARKS AND RECREATION MONTH IN PLANO. AND I DO ENCOURAGE ALL CITIZENS TO JOIN ME AND THE PLANO CITY COUNCIL IN COMMENDING THE PARKS RECREATION DEPARTMENT FOR CREATING AND MAINTAINING THE HIGHEST RANKING SYSTEM AND.
CONGRATULATIONS. [APPLAUSE] THANK YOU. A FEW WORDS.
WE'RE HAPPY TO MAINTAIN THEM. WE LOVE YOUR SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. AND TO THE MANY PARKS AND RECREATION EMPLOYEES THAT MAINTAIN THESE ASSETS EVERY DAY.
THANK THEM AS WELL. THANK YOU MAYOR.
[00:05:04]
DO YOU WANT TO TAKE A PICTURE REAL QUICK? COME ON, COME ON. HI.HOW ARE YOU? GOOD. WE NEED TO BREAK IT UP BREAK IT UP, BREAK IT UP. YES. WE'LL BE. OKAY.
HERE WE ARE. GOOD. THANK YOU JOHN. THANK YOU GUYS. THANK YOU. YOU MADE IT EASY.
OKAY, LET'S MOVE ON TO THE CONSENT AGENDA. THE CONSENT AGENDA.
[CONSENT AGENDA]
THE CONSENT AGENDA WILL BE ACTED UPON IN ONE MOTION AND CONTAINS ITEMS WHICH ARE ROUTINE AND TYPICALLY NONCONTROVERSIAL.MAYOR, I MOVE WE ACCEPT THE CONSENT AGENDA AS PRESENTED WITH THE EXCEPTIONS OF ITEMS G, M AND W.
I SECOND THE MOTION. THANK YOU. I HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA WITH THE EXCEPTION OF G, M AND W, PLEASE VOTE. THANK YOU. MOTION PASSES 8 TO 0. ITEM G. ITEM G.
[(g) To approve the purchase of the Oak Point Recreation Center - Athletic Reprogram Requirements in the estimated amount of $49,098 from Clayton Contracting, Inc., $76,051 from Ponder Company, Inc., $40,724 from CFG Contracting, $3,157 from D & A Building Services, and $10,859 from Sports Imports in the total estimated amount of $179,889 through existing contracts; and authorizing the City Manager to execute all necessary documents. (BuyBoard Contract Nos. 737-24 and 765-25)]
TO APPROVE THE PURCHASE OF THE OAK POINT RECREATION CENTER.ATHLETIC REPROGRAM REQUIREMENTS IN THE ESTIMATED AMOUNT OF $49,098 FROM CLAYTON CONTRACTING INCORPORATED, $76,051 FROM PONDER COMPANY INCORPORATED, $40,724 FROM CFG CONTRACTING, $3,157 FROM D & A BUILDING SERVICES AND $10,859 FROM SPORTS IMPORTS IN THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF $179,889. THROUGH EXISTING CONTRACTS AND AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE ALL NECESSARY DOCUMENTS. GOOD EVENING. CALEB THORNHILL HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.
STAY CLOSE BY, CALEB. IF WE DO AFTERWARDS, WE DO HAVE ONE SPEAKER.
BILL LYLE. GOOD EVENING COUNCIL. THIS MY COMMENTS TONIGHT REALLY HAVE MORE TO DO WITH THE SPACE THAT THESE PICKLEBALL COURTS ARE GOING INTO. THIS HAS LONG BEEN THE SPACE USED BY THE AEROBATS GYMNASTICS PROGRAM.
I'M NOT HERE TO ARGUE FOR OR AGAINST PICKLEBALL.
REASONABLE PEOPLE CAN DISAGREE ABOUT THE BEST USE OF THE FACILITY.
I'M HERE JUST ASKING FOR TRANSPARENCY. LAST FALL I'M SURE YOU ALL WILL REMEMBER THAT THERE WAS.
AND NOW WE HEAR IT'S REALLY ALL ABOUT PICKLEBALL.
MY QUESTION IS SIMPLE. WHY? WHY, WHAT WAS THE RUSH? IF DECLINING ENROLLMENT, STAFFING CHALLENGES AND FINANCIAL CONCERNS HAD BEEN DEVELOPING FOR YEARS, WHY WEREN'T FAMILIES INFORMED EARLIER? WHY WASN'T THE PUBLIC DISCUSSION BEFORE ANNOUNCING THE END OF THE PROGRAM THAT HAD THAT HAD SERVED PLANO RESIDENTS FOR HALF A CENTURY? IF PICKLEBALL COURTS OR OTHER FUTURE USES OF THE FACILITY WERE ALREADY BEING DISCUSSED, WHEN DID THOSE DISCUSSIONS BEGIN AND WHY WASN'T THE INFORMATION SHARED WITH THE PUBLIC AT THAT TIME? WHY WEREN'T THE EMPLOYEES THAT WERE RUNNING ACROBATS OFFERED THE SAME DEAL THAT THE GUY AT THE GOLF COURSE GETS? I MEAN, IT'S WHAT'S REPLACING AEROBATS. NO. YES.
NO, THIS IS ABOUT THE PURCHASE OF THIS.
THAT IS WHERE THIS IS GOING. I'M NOT ARGUING WITH YOU.
I'M TELLING YOU. I'M TELLING YOU IT'S ABOUT THE PURCHASE, AND YOU HAVE TO STAY ON.
STAY ON TOPIC. OKAY. WELL, A LOT OF MY COMMENTS HAVE HAD TO DO WITH PICKLEBALL COURTS.
THAT'S WHAT THEY STARTED OUT WITH. CAN I GET MY TIME BACK? GO. I GUESS THE POINT TO SUMMARIZE THAT IS JUST THAT WE COULD HAVE DONE BETTER WITH THE COMMUNICATION HERE.
THANK YOU. RON SMITH, PARKS AND RECREATION
[00:10:03]
DIRECTOR. THE COUNCIL WAS PROVIDED A MEMORANDUM ABOUT THIS ISSUE.WE RECEIVED SOME FEEDBACK FROM PARTICIPANTS AND FROM COUNCIL.
SO WE PROVIDED A LONGER OFF RAMP. WE'VE COMMUNICATED WITH ALL THE PARTICIPANTS OF THE PROGRAM.
THEY'VE. IF THEY WERE INTERESTED, THEY FOUND A NEW HOME FOR THEIR GYMNASTIC NEEDS.
AND WE FEEL THAT WE DID COMMUNICATE WELL WITH ALL THE PARTICIPANTS, WITH OUR COACHES, AND GIVING EVERYONE AMPLE TIME TO FIND A NEW HOME IF THAT'S WHAT THEY'RE INTERESTED IN DOING. WE ARE LOOKING FORWARD TO RENOVATING THIS SPACE THAT DID HOUSE THE GYMNASTICS TO MEET THE INTENSE NEED OF INDOOR COURT SPACES INCLUDING PICKLEBALL, TABLE TENNIS, BADMINTON AND THOSE TYPES OF SPORTS.
OKAY. ANY QUESTIONS FOR STAFF? RON, IS THERE IS THERE ANY CONTROVERSY THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT? I MEAN, IT SOUNDS LIKE WE'RE DOING WE'RE PURCHASING THIS PORTION OF THE PROGRAM IN ORDER TO MEET A NEW DEMAND. IS THAT IS THAT WHAT I'M UNDERSTANDING? WHAT WE'RE DOING IS WE'RE RENOVATING ONE OF THE AREAS AT THE EXISTING OAK POINT RECREATION CENTER.
IT USED TO HOUSE THE GYMNASTIC AEROBATS PROGRAM.
THE ENROLLMENT THERE DECLINED OVER THE YEARS.
WE SUNSET THAT PROGRAM. NOW WE'RE GOING TO USE THIS MONEY, THIS $179,000, TO RENOVATE THAT SPACE TO ALLOW FOR UP TO THREE PICKLEBALL COURTS, SEVERAL BADMINTON, THREE BADMINTON COURTS, DEPENDING ON HOW WE WANT TO PROGRAM IT, FREEING UP SPACE TO MEET THE GROWING DEMAND FOR THOSE INDOOR SPORTS.
YEAH, I SEEM TO REMEMBER A I THINK IT WAS A YEAR, A COUPLE OF YEARS BACK, THERE WAS SOME TYPE OF DISCUSSION WITH REGARD TO THE GYMNASTIC TEAM. SO WERE THEY FINALLY RELOCATED OR WAS THERE SOME SORT OF SOLUTION TO THEIR ISSUES? YEAH, WE JUST INFORMED THE PATRONS THAT THAT PROGRAM WAS NO LONGER GOING TO BE OFFERED BY PARKS AND RECREATION, AND THOSE THAT WANTED TO FIND A NEW GYMNASIUM HAVE ALREADY DONE SO.
GOT IT. OKAY. SO BASICALLY RUNNING THAT PROGRAM WAS NOT BENEFICIAL FOR THE USE OF SPACE? THAT'S RIGHT. OKAY. THANK YOU. I MOVE TO APPROVE, YOUR HONOR.
JUDGE. MAYOR. JUDGE. WHATEVER. [LAUGHTER]. SECOND THAT.
SO I HAVE A MOTION, A SECOND TO APPROVE ITEM G, PLEASE VOTE.
MOTION PASSES 8 TO 0. ITEM M. ITEM M TO
[(m)
To approve an expenditure for Architectural Services for the Pecan Hollow Golf Maintenance Building Renovations in the amount of $125,000 from PGAL, Inc. for the Engineering - Facilities Division; and authorizing the City Manager to execute all necessary documents.
]APPROVE AN EXPENDITURE FOR ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES FOR THE PECAN HOLLOW GOLF MAINTENANCE BUILDING RENOVATIONS IN THE AMOUNT OF $125,000 FROM PGAL INCORPORATED FOR THE ENGINEERING FACILITIES DIVISION AND AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE ALL NECESSARY DOCUMENTS.AGAIN, CALEB THORNHILL, DIRECTOR OF ENGINEERING, HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU HAVE. ALL RIGHT.
CALEB, WHO OWNS THE BUILDING ON THE GOLF COURSE? CITY OF PLANO. SO CITY OF PLANO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR MAINTAINING AND MAKE SURE IT'S WORKABLE AND STILL USABLE.
CORRECT? THAT'S CORRECT. THANK YOU. OKAY. WE HAVE A SPEAKER, CALEB.
ALL RIGHT. BILL LYLE. GOOD EVENING COUNCIL. MY COMMENTS ON THIS TOPIC REALLY HAVE TO DO WITH THE FUNDING SOURCE. YOU ALL WILL RECALL AT TWO MEETINGS AGO, RON SMITH MADE THESE COMMENTS.
HE SAID ZERO. AND THIS IS THE TRANSCRIPT FROM THE MEETING.
HE SAID. ZERO OF THE CITY'S GENERAL FUND OR TAXPAYER DOLLARS GO TO MAINTAIN PECAN HOLLOW.
SO THE BEAUTIFUL COURSE THAT PEOPLE PLAY IS MAINTAINED 100% AT THE COST OF THE GOLFERS THEMSELVES.
NO TAXPAYER THAT IS DISINTERESTED IN GOLF PAYS ANYTHING TO MAINTAIN PECAN HOLLOW.
AND THE CITY GETS 5%. I THINK HE MEANT 95 THERE.
ZERO TAX DOLLARS FROM THE RESIDENTS THAT DON'T PLAY GOLF.
[00:15:04]
COURSE. AND THE FUNDING SOURCE ON THIS IS LISTED AS THE CAPITAL MAINTENANCE FUND.AND SO MY QUESTION IS, DOES THE GOLF FUND, THE ENTERPRISE FUND THAT RON TOLD US ABOUT TWO MEETINGS AGO, DOES THAT GO INTO THE CAPITAL MAINTENANCE FUND, OR IS THIS ACTUALLY TAX DOLLARS THAT GOES TO SUPPORT THE FACILITY THAT SUPPORTS THE MAINTENANCE ON THE GOLF COURSE? THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
RON SMITH, PARKS AND RECREATION THE GOLF FUND THAT IS COLLECTED WHEN GOLFERS PAY.
THE GREEN FEE PAYS FOR ALL OF THE EMPLOYEES THAT MAINTAIN THE COURSE, THEIR SALARIES, THEIR BENEFITS AND IT PAYS FOR ALL THE EQUIPMENT, THE FUEL AND EVERYTHING THAT THEY USE TO MAINTAIN THE COURSE.
THE BUILDING ITSELF THAT HOUSES THAT EQUIPMENT IS CITY OWNED.
IT'S A CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT. IT'S A CAPITAL PROJECT.
SO THE RENOVATION OF THAT WOULD LIKELY AND RIGHTFULLY COME OUT OF A CAPITAL FUNDING, IN THIS CASE, THE CAPITAL MAINTENANCE FUND. THANK YOU. ANY QUESTIONS FOR RON? SO FOR CLARIFICATION, THE GOLF FUND PAYS FOR THE SUPERINTENDENTS OF THE COURSE ITSELF MAINTENANCE, MOWING, IRRIGATION, WATER, ALL THE FERTILIZER, ALL THAT.
BUT THE BUILDING ITSELF, THE CLUBHOUSE, THE UPSTAIRS DINING AREA, THE MAINTENANCE FACILITY, THOSE ARE OWNED BY THE CITY, SO ANY REPAIRS OR MAINTENANCE WOULD BE FROM THE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT? THAT'S RIGHT. THEY FALL UNDER THE FACILITIES DIVISION OF THE ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT JUST LIKE ANY OTHER CITY FACILITY DOES.
BUT YOU'RE CORRECT THAT THE COST TO MAINTAIN THE COURSE PAID FOR EXCLUSIVELY BY THE GOLF FUND.
OKAY. THANK YOU. MAYOR MOVE TO APPROVE. SECOND DID I GET YOU? SORRY. SORRY, MAYOR. I DO HAVE AN ADDITIONAL QUESTION.
OKAY. SO IT SAYS 125 FOR ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES.
BUT DOES THIS INCLUDE THE ENTIRE PROJECT OR IS IT JUST THE DESIGNING OR? CALEB, WOULD YOU BE ABLE TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION? FACILITIES. IT'S USUALLY 10% TO 20%.
I WOULD SAY THAT'S PROBABLY A FAIR ESTIMATE. SOMEWHERE BETWEEN 10% AND 20%.
SO WE'RE BIDDING FIRST. CORRECT. THANK YOU. SO I HAVE A MOTION A SECOND.
COUNCIL MEMBER KEHR AND MARIA TU WAS THE SECOND.
TO APPROVE ITEM M, PLEASE VOTE. MOTION PASSES 8 TO 0. ITEM W.
[(w) To act in response to a petition for recognition, received on May 26, 2026, on behalf of the Plano Police Association, FOP Lodge 777, to be the sole and exclusive bargaining agent for Plano Police Department police officers, in accordance with the provisions of the meet and confer statute as set forth in Texas Local Government Code, Chapter 142 and granting recognition of the Association as requested in the petition and determining that the City of Plano may and shall meet and confer with said Association without conducting an election by the voters; and providing an effective date.]
ITEM W TO ACT IN RESPONSE TO A PETITION FOR RECOGNITION RECEIVED ON MAY 26TH, 2026 ON BEHALF OF THE PLANO POLICE ASSOCIATION, FOP LODGE 777 TO BE THE SOLE AND EXCLUSIVE BARGAINING AGENT FOR THE PLANO POLICE DEPARTMENT POLICE OFFICERS, IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE MEET AND CONFER STATUTE AS SET FORTH IN TEXAS LOCAL GOVERNMENT CODE, CHAPTER 142, AND GRANTING RECOGNITION OF THE ASSOCIATION AS A REQUEST, AS REQUESTED IN THE PETITION, AND DETERMINING THAT THE CITY OF PLANO MAY AND SHALL MEET AND CONFER WITH SAID ASSOCIATION WITHOUT CONDUCTING AN ELECTION BY THE VOTERS AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. I BELIEVE WE HAVE A SPEAKER FOR THIS TOO.WE DO. MR. LYLE. SECTION 2-109 OF THE PLANO CODE OF ORDINANCES ESTABLISHES A CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTION RECUSAL REQUIREMENT FOR THE MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL.
UNDER THAT ORDINANCE, A COUNCIL MEMBER WHO HAS RECEIVED CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTIONS EXCEEDING $1,000 FROM A PERSON OR ENTITY WITH SUBSTANTIAL BUSINESS INTEREST IN A MATTER BEFORE THE COUNCIL MAY BE SUBJECT TO RECUSAL. THE ORDINANCE DEFINES CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTION BROADLY.
IT INCLUDES NOT ONLY MONETARY DONATIONS, BUT ALSO LOANS, OFFSETS TO EXPENDITURES AND IN-KIND CONTRIBUTIONS DURING RECENT ELECTION CYCLES THE PLANO POLICE ASSOCIATION APPEARS TO HAVE EXPENDED FUNDS IN THE AMOUNT OF ABOUT $19,000 TO PRODUCE AND DISTRIBUTE CAMPAIGN MATERIALS, SUPPORTING CERTAIN CANDIDATES IN AMOUNTS EXCEEDING $1,000 THRESHOLD.
[00:20:02]
THOSE EXPENDITURES WERE MADE FOR THE DIRECT POLITICAL BENEFIT OF THE ENDORSED CANDIDATES. WHEN THOSE CANDIDATES THEN PROMOTED, PUBLICIZED AND RELIED ON THOSE ENDORSEMENTS THROUGH WEBSITES, SIGNAGE, FACEBOOK POSTS AND OTHER CAMPAIGN COMMUNICATIONS, THEY ACCEPTED AND BENEFITED FROM THAT SUPPORT.SECTION 2-109 IS CLEAR. IT SHALL BE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTOR AND NOT THE CITY COUNCIL MEMBER, TO IDENTIFY THEIR SUBSTANTIAL BUSINESS INTERESTS IMPACTED BY THIS SECTION.
THAT LANGUAGE PLACES THE DISCLOSURE BURDEN SQUARELY ON THE CONTRIBUTOR.
THE QUESTION, THEN, IS STRAIGHTFORWARD SHOULD AN ORGANIZATION REPRESENTING LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS BE EXPECTED TO FOLLOW THE LAW? THE RULE OF LAW CANNOT BE SELECTIVE, APPLIED ONLY WHEN CONVENIENT OR WHEN IT SERVES A PREFERRED OUTCOME.
IF THIS MEASURE DOES NOT PASS TODAY, THE ISSUE PROCEEDS TO THE VOTERS.
THAT IS NOT A FAILURE OF PROCESS. THAT IS THE PROCESS SUBMITTING THIS MATTER TO THE ELECTORATE.
ELECTORATE WOULD PRESERVE PUBLIC CONFIDENCE AND RECOGNIZE AN IMPORTANT FACT.
SUPPORT FOR THIS REQUEST IS NOT UNANIMOUS WITHIN THE POLICE DEPARTMENT ITSELF.
APPROXIMATELY 28% OF PLANO POLICE OFFICERS HAVE CHOSEN NOT TO SIGN THIS REQUEST.
IT IS ALSO MY UNDERSTANDING THAT THE FINANCIAL BURDEN OF SUCH AN ELECTION WOULD FALL TO THE PPA.
IF THE PPA CHOOSES NOT TO BEAR THAT COST, THAT DECISION DOES NOT PREVENT THE CITY FROM CONTINUING TO NEGOTIATE WITH THE PPA IN GOOD FAITH, NOR DOES IT PREVENT THE CITY FROM ENGAGING WITH THE OTHER 28% OF OFFICERS WHO CHOOSE NOT TO BE REPRESENTED BY THE PPA.
THE COUNCIL SHOULD NOT BE PLACED IN THE POSITION OF REWARDING POLITICAL SUPPORT, OVERLOOKING POTENTIAL CONFLICTS OR BYPASSING THE VOTERS SIMPLY BECAUSE AN INTERESTED PARTY WOULD PREFER A MORE CONVENIENT OUTCOME. THE CLEANER COURSE, THE LEGALLY SOUND COURSE AND THE COURSE MOST CONSISTENT WITH PUBLIC TRUST IS TO LET THE VOTERS DECIDE. IN ADDITION, I WOULD JUST REMIND MARIA YOU WERE NEVER SUPPORTED BY THE PPA.
VIDAL HAYDEN PADGETT WAS SUPPORTED IN LIEU OF YOU.
AND I THINK THAT WAS BECAUSE OF HAYDEN PADGETT'S POLITICAL CONSULTANT.
AND SO, YOU KNOW, AT THE VERY LEAST, I WOULD JUST WRAP UP GOING BACK TO THE POINT WHERE IT'S THE POLITICAL ORGANIZATIONS RESPONSIBILITY TO TELL Y'ALL, HEY, YOU'VE GOT TO RECUSE YOURSELF. I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE EITHER GET RID OF THAT LAW OR FOLLOW IT.
MAYOR COUNCIL. IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS, WE'RE HAPPY TO PROVIDE. LET ME TRY LET ME TRY TO UNDERSTAND WHAT MR. LYLE IS SAYING VERSUS WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO DO TODAY.
SO BASICALLY, WE ARE ASKING, I MEAN, THE PLANO POLICE ASSOCIATION IS ASKING TO SPEAK TO CITY COUNCIL REGARDING CERTAIN ISSUES. IS THAT RIGHT? IT IS ACTUALLY SPEAKING TO MANAGEMENT.
MANAGEMENT. NOT REALLY TO CITY COUNCIL REGARDING ANY ISSUES THAT'S IN FRONT OF CITY COUNCIL? SO RIGHT NOW WE DON'T KNOW QUITE WHAT THE POINT OF POLICE ASSOCIATION IS GOING TO BE ASKING FOR.
I SEE. IT'S VERY PRELIMINARY RIGHT NOW. SO THIS WOULD THIS WOULD RECOGNIZE THEM AS THE NEGOTIATING AGENT AND ALLOW THE CITY MANAGEMENT TO MEET WITH THE ASSOCIATION REPRESENTING THOSE OFFICERS TO ACTUALLY ENGAGE IN DISCUSSIONS AND POTENTIALLY NEGOTIATIONS TO SEE WHAT THE ISSUES ARE.
THEY'RE ASKING TO TALK TO SOMEBODY IN THE CITY? THAT'S CORRECT. RIGHT NOW, WE UNDERSTAND THERE ARE ISSUES.
WE JUST DON'T KNOW WHAT ISSUES WE'RE TALKING ABOUT.
OKAY. SO THIS CURRENTLY THIS ON THE AGENDA BASICALLY ONLY GIVE A CONSENT TO ALLOW CITY MANAGER AND TEAM TO TALK TO THEM. CORRECT. NOT TO MAKE ANY DECISIONS ABOUT ANYTHING, BUT JUST TO TALK, TO SEE WHETHER OR NOT THIS NEEDS TO GO TO A DIFFERENT A DIFFERENT AVENUE, OR IT NEEDS TO COME BACK TO COUNCIL OR IT NEEDS TO GO TO A, YOU KNOW, OTHER OTHER CONSULTANT OR POTENTIALLY WHATEVER.
IS THAT MY UNDERSTANDING? ANY RESULT WILL HAVE TO COME BACK TO THE CITY COUNCIL.
OKAY. SO AT THIS POINT, THIS IS VERY, VERY, VERY PRELIMINARY.
CORRECT. OKAY. WITH THAT IN MIND, I MOVE TO APPROVE.
[00:25:03]
ALL RIGHT. I'D ALSO LIKE TO BRING UP A POINT HERE IN THAT WE'RE RIGHT AT THE VERY BEGINNING STAGES OF THE BUDGETS FOR THIS SEASON.AND PART OF THAT BUDGET CYCLE IS ADDRESSING PUBLIC SAFETY.
AND AS I CAN ATTEST FOR EVERYONE ON THIS BOARD, PUBLIC SAFETY IS THE MOST IMPORTANT CRITICAL ITEM THAT WE ARE FACED WITH AS COUNCIL MEMBERS. AND WE LOOKED AT THE SAFEGUARD OF ALL OUR CITIZENS.
SO THIS BEING A PRELIMINARY DISCUSSION BETWEEN THE PLANO POLICE ASSOCIATION AND OUR MANAGEMENT TEAM TO FIND OUT IF THERE MAY BE ANY COST IMPACTS THAT MAY COME OUT OF THAT IS REAL CRITICAL. I THINK.
REGARDING, YOU KNOW. AGAIN. PUBLIC SAFETY OR WHATEVER.
I SEE. OKAY. AND THAT'S WHAT I WAS GETTING AT.
ALL RIGHT. SO WITH THAT BEING SAID, I'LL SECOND THE MOTION.
SO I HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE ITEM W.
PLEASE VOTE. MOTION PASSES 8 TO 0. NEXT ITEM IS INDIVIDUAL ITEMS FOR
[(1)
Public Hearing and consideration of an Ordinance to approve the terms and conditions of an Interlocal Agreement and Memorandum of Understanding by and between the City of Plano, the City of McKinney, the City of Frisco, and the Collin County Sheriff’s Office for the disbursement of the 2025 Edward Byrne Justice Assistance Grant funds; authorizing its execution by the City Manager or his authorized designee; and providing an effective date.
]INDIVIDUAL CONSIDERATION. ITEMS FOR INDIVIDUAL CONSIDERATION.
THE PRESIDING OFFICER MAY AMEND THESE TIMES AS DEEMED NECESSARY.
THE PRESIDING OFFICER WILL ESTABLISH TIME LIMITS BASED UPON THE NUMBER OF SPEAKER REQUESTS, LENGTH OF THE AGENDA, AND TO INSURE MEETING EFFICIENCY, AND MAY INCLUDE A CUMULATIVE TIME LIMIT.
ITEM NUMBER 1. PUBLIC HEARING AND CONSIDERATION OF AN ORDINANCE TO APPROVE THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF AN INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT AND MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING BY AND BETWEEN THE CITY OF PLANO, THE CITY OF MCKINNEY, THE CITY OF FRISCO, AND THE COLLIN COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT FOR THE DISBURSEMENT OF THE 2025 EDWARD BYRNE JUSTICE ASSISTANT GRANT FUNDS.
AUTHORIZING ITS EXECUTION BY THE CITY MANAGER OR HIS DESIGNEE AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
GOOD EVENING, MAYOR AND COUNCIL. THE BYRNE JUSTICE ASSISTANCE GRANT, OR JAG GRANT, AS WE CALL IT, IS WHAT'S CALLED A FORMULA GRANT. THEY USE OUR CRIME RATE DATA, OUR POPULATION, TO COME UP WITH THIS GRANT AMOUNT.
THIS YEAR, THE AMOUNT IS ROUGHLY $64,000. OUR SHARE OF PLANO SHARE OF THAT IS 24.
WE HAVE TO SPLIT THAT GRANT AMOUNT WITH OTHER CITIES IN OUR COUNTY WITH ALLEN, FRISCO, AND MCKINNEY.
AS I SAID, OUR SHARE IS ABOUT. AND ALSO THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE GETS A SHARE OF THAT TOO.
THE PROJECT THAT WE'RE GOING TO USE OUR PORTION OF THE GRANT FOR IS TO.
WE'RE GOING TO SWAP OUT OUR SIDEARMS. WE'VE BEEN CARRYING THOSE FOR ABOUT TEN YEARS NOW.
THAT'S GOING TO BE A LOT MORE THAN WHAT WE GET OUT OF THIS $24,000. SO WE'RE GOING TO BUY ABOUT 20 OF THOSE GUNS FOR OUR NEW RECRUITS COMING IN. WE'RE LOOKING AT A GLOCK 17. IT'LL HAVE THE OPTIC IT WILL COME WITH IT. SO IT'S GOING TO BE A GOOD VALUE FOR US INSTEAD OF BUYING THEM SEPARATELY.
BUT BEFORE WE GO AND PURCHASE 4 OR 500 OF THOSE, WE'RE GOING TO PURCHASE ABOUT 20.
MAKE SURE THAT THEY ARE INTEGRATED, THAT THEY'RE WORKING. WE DON'T HAVE ANY TRAINING ISSUES. AND THEN LATER THIS YEAR, EARLY NEXT YEAR, CALENDAR YEAR, WE WILL COMPLETE THAT PURCHASE OF ABOUT 4 OR 500 OTHER GUNS. SO THAT'S THE GRANT.
THAT'S WHY I'M BRIEFING YOU ON IT. AND THAT'S WHAT WE PLAN ON DOING WITH THE MONEY. THANK YOU CHIEF.
ANY QUESTIONS FOR CHIEF? OKAY. THANK YOU, THANK YOU.
I'LL OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING. DO YOU HAVE ANY SPEAKERS? THERE ARE NO SPEAKERS ON THIS ITEM. ALL RIGHT. CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING.
COMBINE THE COMMENTS TO THE COUNCIL. MAYOR, I MOVE TO APPROVE.
MAYOR, I SECOND. I'D LIKE TO MAKE A COMMENT AS WELL.
SO I THINK THIS IS REALLY A GOOD THING TO MOVE FORWARD ON.
ALL RIGHT. SO WE HAVE A MOTION AND SECOND TO APPROVE ITEM NUMBER ONE PLEASE VOTE.
[00:30:01]
MOTION PASSES 8 TO 0. MOVING ON TO COMMENTS OF PUBLIC INTEREST.[COMMENTS OF PUBLIC INTEREST]
COMMENTS OF PUBLIC INTEREST. THIS PORTION OF THE MEETING IS TO ALLOW UP TO THREE MINUTES PER SPEAKER, WITH 30 TOTAL MINUTES ON ITEMS OF INTEREST OR CONCERN, AND NOT ON ITEMS THAT ARE ON THE CURRENT AGENDA.THE COUNCIL MAY NOT DISCUSS THESE ITEMS, BUT MAY RESPOND WITH FACTUAL OR POLICY INFORMATION.
YEAH, WE HAVE OVER 30 MINUTES OF SPEAKERS. SO IF WE LEFT IT AT THREE MINUTES PER SPEAKER.
SO I'M GOING TO BRING IT DOWN TO TWO MINUTES PER SPEAKER.
AND WE CAN START WITH THE FIRST ONE. THE FIRST SPEAKER IS NCBW DALLAS CHAPTER.
GOOD EVENING, MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL CONSTITUENTS.
AND SO JUST FOR A MINUTE OR SO, I WANT TO SHINE A LIGHT ON MATERNAL HEALTH, BLACK MATERNAL HEALTH.
CHILDREN ARE IMPACTED IN OUR COMMUNITIES, LOSE VITAL CONTRIBUTORS AND LEADERS.
AND SO BLACK MATERNAL HEALTH IS SIMPLY NOT A HEALTH CARE ISSUE.
BUT IT IS A COMMUNITY ISSUE. IT IS AN ECONOMIC ISSUE AND A QUALITY OF LIFE ISSUE.
AND SO TO ADVANCE THIS WORK, WE WOULD LIKE TO ENCOURAGE THE PLANO CITY COUNCIL TO ISSUE AN ANNUAL PROCLAMATION RECOGNIZING BLACK MATERNAL HEALTH WEEK, APRIL 11TH THROUGH APRIL 17TH OF EACH YEAR.
AND OUR THIRD REQUEST IS, WE WOULD LIKE TO ESTABLISH OR FOR YOU TO CONSIDER ESTABLISHING A PLANO BLACK MATERNAL HEALTH TASK FORCE OR ADVISORY COMMITTEE COMPOSED OF HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS, PUBLIC HEALTH LEADERS, COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS, FAITH LEADERS AND RESIDENTS TO IDENTIFY LOCAL BLACK MATERNAL HEALTH PRIORITIES AND RECOMMEND COMMUNITY BASED SOLUTIONS AND STRENGTHEN COLLABORATIONS ACROSS THE SECTORS. 20 SECONDS.
AND SO WHAT WE'RE ASKING IS THAT WE WOULD LOVE TO FOLLOW UP WITH EACH CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE HERE TO TALK ABOUT HOW WE CAN COLLABORATE AND WORK TOGETHER IN THE COMMUNITY.
AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH YOU IN THE FUTURE.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THE NEXT SPEAKER IS KYLE MCGEEAN, AND HE WILL BE FOLLOWED BY SHIRLEY LAWSON.
GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS KYLE MCGEEAN I'M A MEMBER OF DSA NORTH TEXAS AND REVOLUTIONARY FRONT DFW.
IT'S BEEN ALMOST TWO MONTHS SINCE I LAST SPOKE TO THIS COUNCIL ABOUT PLANO'S DATA CENTER DILEMMA.
SO WHAT WAS I SUPPOSED TO DO? ON THAT EVENING, I WAS THE SOLE ATTENDEE CONCERNED ABOUT THIS TOPIC.
TONIGHT, I AM NOT ALONE THAT'S WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU IGNORE A PROBLEM COUNCIL MEMBERS.
IT DOESN'T GO AWAY. IT JUST GETS BIGGER. IN FACT, THE STATEWIDE BACKLASH AGAINST DATA CENTER DEVELOPMENT HAS GROWN SO COLOSSAL THAT GREG ABBOTT, A MAN SO CORRUPT THAT HIS FIRST WORD AS A CHILD WAS BRIBE.
NOBODY SHOULD BELIEVE HIM, OF COURSE, BUT HE CAN TELL WHERE THE POLITICAL WINDS ARE BLOWING.
AND THEY RIGHTFULLY TERRIFY HIM. CONSIDER THIS QUESTION COUNCIL MEMBERS.
DO YOU REALLY WANT GREG ABBOTT, OF ALL CREATURES, TO LEAVE YOU GUYS IN THE DUST? IF NOT, THEN YOU HAVE A COUPLE OF OPTIONS. FIRST, YOU CAN START THE PROCESS OF EXPLORING A DATA CENTER MORATORIUM.
DOCTOR THOMAS, WHEN YOU FILLED OUT BALLOTPEDIA'S CANDIDATE CORRECTION SORRY CONNECTION SURVEY LAST YEAR, YOU LISTED ZONING REFORM AS SOMETHING YOU'RE PASSIONATE ABOUT.
THIS WOULD BE AN EXCELLENT OPPORTUNITY TO FLEX THAT MUSCLE AND SHOW YOUR COLLEAGUES HOW IT'S DONE.
[00:35:03]
THE OWNING CLASS AND THE WORKING CLASS. WHO GETS TO CONTROL THE FUTURE? THE PEOPLE OR THE PROFITEERS? 20 SECONDS. I KNOW WHICH SIDE I'M ON COUNCIL MEMBERS.WHICH SIDE ARE YOU ON? [APPLAUSE] SHIRLEY LAWSON.
SHIRLEY WILL BE FOLLOWED BY CONNOR BOYKIN AND SANJAY SAI.
AND TWO MINUTES. TWO. HELLO. HI, EVERYBODY. MY NAME IS SHIRLEY LAWSON.
I'M HERE WITH MY FRIEND KYLE AND MY FRIENDS FROM DEMOCRATIC SOCIALISTS OF AMERICA.
MY ONLY GOAL HERE TONIGHT IS TO LET YOU KNOW THAT ACTUALLY IS TO PUT YOU ALL ON NOTICE.
I'VE NOTICED THAT AT LEAST FOUR OF YOU WILL BE UP FOR REELECTION NEXT YEAR IN 2027.
I DON'T HAVE A JOB. I'M A FULL TIME DO WHATEVER I FEEL LIKE PERSON.
AND IF OUR NEEDS AREN'T MET AND THIS THE ITEM AGENDAS THAT HE HAS SUGGESTED DON'T GET ON HERE THAT'S WHAT I'M GOING TO SPEND ALL MY TIME DOING. I CANNOT VOTE HERE, UNFORTUNATELY, BECAUSE I'M NOT ACTUALLY FROM PLANO, WHICH WOULDN'T BE A CONCERN IF YOU GUYS BUILT A DOME OVER PLANO THAT WOULD CONTAIN ALL THE POLLUTION AND THE ADDITIONAL HEAT THAT IS GOING TO COME FROM THESE AI DATA CENTER MONSTROSITIES.
SO I HAVE PLENTY OF TIME. I CAN RECRUIT PEOPLE.
I CAN CALL PEOPLE, I CAN BLOCK WALK FOR THESE PEOPLE.
AND I'VE ALREADY GOT TWO OF THEM IN MIND. SO WITH THAT IN MIND, THAT'S ALL I HAVE.
HAVE A NICE NIGHT. [APPLAUSE] CONNOR BOYKIN.
AS A PLANO RESIDENT, IT'S APPALLING TO SEE MILLIONS OF DOLLARS BEING SPENT ON PROJECTS WE DON'T NEED, DON'T WANT, AND DIDN'T ASK FOR. WHILE CONCERNS ABOUT PUBLIC SERVICES AND INFRASTRUCTURE ARE QUIETLY IGNORED. WE'LL START WITH THE DATA CENTERS OF COURSE, COREWEAVE MIGHT SOUND FAMILIAR. IT'S AN AI CLOUD COMPUTING BEHEMOTH THAT JOINED THE NASDAQ 100 EARLIER TODAY, AND PLANO CITY COUNCIL UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED HUGE TAX REBATES FOR COREWEAVE DATA CENTER RIGHT OFF COURT ROAD.
BUT THEY'RE NOT ALONE. ON THE 23RD OF FEBRUARY, THE COUNCIL UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED THE LARGEST INCENTIVES PACKAGE IN PLANO'S HISTORY FOR AT&T, INCLUDING A $20 MILLION GRANT AND TAX BREAKS TOTALING OUT TO POTENTIALLY $100 MILLION.
DON'T YOU THINK THAT THOSE TAX DOLLARS COULD BE BETTER SPENT ADDRESSING THE COMMUNITY'S NEEDS DIRECTLY? BECAUSE I CAN ASSURE YOU, THERE ARE NEIGHBORHOODS IN THIS CITY THAT HAVE BEEN NEGLECTED. TAKE THE DOUGLASS COMMUNITY.
I HAVE HAD THE PLEASURE OF MEETING A LOT OF DOUGLASS' RESIDENTS OVER THE PAST YEAR, AND I'VE HAD THE CHANCE TO HEAR SOME OF THEIR THOUGHTS ABOUT WHAT COULD IMPROVE THEIR COMMUNITY. FOR STARTERS, THE RECREATIONAL CENTER.
IT'S SUMMER VACATION AND THE REC CENTER IS ONLY OPEN TWO HOURS A DAY FROM MONDAY THROUGH FRIDAY, FOUR HOURS ON SATURDAY, AND IT ISN'T OPEN AT ALL ON SUNDAYS.
OTHER COMMENTS POINTED OUT ISSUES WITH THE WATER FOUNTAINS AND PARK LIGHTS AT STIMPSON AND DRAKE PARK, A DEAD STREET LIGHT THAT WE SAW ON 13TH STREET CARS SPEEDING DOWN I AVENUE AS THEY PASS THROUGH THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
AND THESE ARE JUST A FEW OF THE COMMENTS THAT WE HEARD.
BUT THE GOOD NEWS IS IT DOES NOT TAKE A MASSIVE TAX BREAK TO SOLVE THESE PROBLEMS. 20 SECONDS. ASK THE PEOPLE OF PLANO WHAT THEY NEED AND WANT INSTEAD OF DECIDING FOR THEM BECAUSE DOUGLAS IS JUST ONE OF THESE NEIGHBORHOODS, THERE ARE MANY OTHERS WITH THE SAME CONCERNS, I ASSURE YOU. WE NEED MORE PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT IN DECISION MAKING.
THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] SANJAY SAI, FOLLOWED BY NATHAN TAN.
AND BEFORE YOU SAY ANYTHING ABOUT ME, I'M ACTUALLY I'M NOT AGAINST AI OR INNOVATION.
WHAT HAPPENS IS YOU CAN JUST SAY HI LIKE YOU SAY HI TO CHATGPT.
YOUR COMPUTER IS GOING TO HEAT UP AND IT'S NOT GOING TO WORK.
[00:40:02]
COMPUTERS ARE GOING TO GET HOT. IT'S GOING TO GET FROZEN. NOW LET'S LET'S APPLY THAT TO SCALE.THESE CORPORATIONS ARE GOING TO RELEASE THESE MODELS OUT TO THE PUBLIC AND PEOPLE ARE GOING TO USE LIKE THEY'RE GOING TO CREATE RANDOM VIDEOS, THEY'RE GOING TO CREATE AI FRUIT VIDEOS OR SOMETHING.
AND IMAGINE IF YOUR LOCAL COMPUTER BURNS OR HEATS UP BECAUSE OF A SIMPLE HI PROMPT.
IMAGINE WHAT WOULD HAPPEN WHEN THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE ARE USING THAT DATA CENTER AT SCALE.
WELL, IT'S GOING TO RELEASE A LOT OF HEAT. AND TO COOL THAT DOWN, YOU NEED AN EXCESS AMOUNT OF WATER, A RIDICULOUS AMOUNT OF WATER. AND YOU ALSO NEED A RIDICULOUS AMOUNT OF ELECTRICITY TO DO THESE COMPUTATIONS FOR THAT AI MODEL TO WORK.
AND SO WHAT HAPPENS IS WE'VE SEEN IN COUNTIES IN GEORGIA AND COUNTIES IN ARIZONA, THE WATER PRESSURE IN THE AREA ACTUALLY DECREASES TO THE POINT YOU TURN ON THE SHOWER AND IT ACTUALLY COMES OUT PRETTY SLOW. THEIR ELECTRICITY BILLS HAVE GONE UP, THEIR WATER BILLS HAVE GONE UP.
AND DO YOU REALLY WANT THAT FOR THE 300,000 RESIDENTS OF PLANO HERE? SO AGAIN, LIKE I'M SAYING, I'M NOT AGAINST INNOVATION. IN FACT, IF YOU WERE TO IMPOSE RESTRICTIONS ON DATA CENTERS HERE, PUT A MORATORIUM, IT WOULD ACTUALLY INCENTIVIZE SOME OF THESE COMPANIES TO FIND ALTERNATIVE WAYS TO REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF ELECTRICITY AND WATER REQUIRED.
RIGHT NOW THEY'RE JUST USING ALL THE LAND THEY CAN.
BUT IF YOU PUT A MORATORIUM ON DATA CENTERS, YOU WON'T BE STIFLING INNOVATION.
[APPLAUSE] NATHAN TAN. GOOD EVENING, MAYORS AND MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. MY NAME IS NATHAN TAN. I'M 17 AND A RISING HIGH SCHOOL SENIOR AT SAINT MARK'S SCHOOL OF TEXAS, AND I LIVE HERE IN PLANO. I FOUNDED THE SHARED SKIES INITIATIVE, A YOUTH LED NONPROFIT, AFTER A SEVEN YEAR OLD I TUTOR LOOKED AT THE HAZY SKY AND ASKED ME WHY IT LOOKED THE WAY IT DID, AND HE COULD FEEL THAT SOMETHING WAS WRONG, BUT HE HAD NO WAY TO MEASURE IT.
AND THAT IS WHY I AM WORRIED ABOUT WHAT IS COMING TO PLANO.
DATA CENTERS RUN ON ENORMOUS AROUND THE CLOCK ELECTRICITY AND TO GUARANTEE THAT POWER, THEY INSTALL DIESEL BACKUP GENERATORS THAT ARE TESTED 50 TO 150 HOURS EVERY YEAR, AND A GROWING NUMBER NOW BUILD GAS TURBINES ON SITE TO RUN FULL TIME.
NATIONWIDE, RESEARCHERS ALREADY TIE THIS INDUSTRY TO ABOUT 1300 PREMATURE DEATHS, HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF ASTHMA CASES, AND CLOSE TO $20 BILLION IN HEALTH COSTS EVERY YEAR.
AND A NATIONAL REVIEW FOUND THAT NEARLY HALF OF THESE FACILITIES ARE BUILT IN NEIGHBORHOODS THAT ALREADY CARRY ABOVE AVERAGE POLLUTION, DISPROPORTIONATELY COMMUNITIES OF COLOR, AND LOWER INCOME FAMILIES WHO CAN LEAST AFFORD THAT BURDEN.
I'M 17. I CAN'T VOTE YET, BUT I WILL BE BREATHING PLANO'S AIR LONG AFTER TONIGHT.
AND SO WILL EVERY KID IN THIS CITY. I'M ASKING YOU TO PASS A MORATORIUM ON NEW DATA CENTERS AND TAKE THE TIME TO LOOK HONESTLY AT THE AIR, THE WATER AND THE BILLS AND INVEST IN THE PEOPLE OF PLANO FIRST.
THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] THE NEXT SPEAKER IS AUGUST MCFARLAND.
AUGUST. THEN WE WILL MOVE ON TO PEGAH MOVAHEDI.
GOOD AFTERNOON. FIRST OFF, SHUN THOMAS, YOU GOT SO MANY PEOPLE COMING OUT TO VOTE FOR YOU.
I'M SO EXCITED THAT YOU WON YOUR ELECTION, SO CONGRATULATIONS.
I AM HERE TODAY TO ASK FOR A MORATORIUM ON DATA CENTERS.
I WANTED TO SHARE A COUPLE STATISTICS FOR YOU GUYS.
THERE HAVE BEEN OVER 4000 DATA CENTERS IN OPERATION IN VIRGINIA, TEXAS AND CALIFORNIA.
JUST THOSE STATES. THERE ARE 3000 MORE PLANNED.
THIS TRIPLES THE AMOUNT OF WATER THAT'S GOING TO BE USED FROM 4.4% TO 12% IN THE NATION.
AND I CAN PROVIDE ALL THE STATISTICS AS WELL.
AND ALSO REMEMBER THAT YOU GUYS STILL BREATHE THE SAME AIR.
[00:45:05]
LIKE IT DID A FEW YEARS AGO. I KNOW FOR ME MY POWER WAS OUT FOR FIVE DAYS AND I HAVE A SPECIAL NEEDS DAUGHTER.SO THAT WAS A VERY BIG CHALLENGE. AND WHAT WOULD WE DO THEN? JUST I REALLY WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU ALL TO THINK ABOUT THE CONSEQUENCES BECAUSE IT DOESN'T MATTER HOW MUCH MONEY YOU HAVE.
20 SECONDS. THIS WILL IMPACT EVERY SINGLE PERSON HERE.
AND YEAH. I'M SORRY, THIS IS I REALLY JUST WANT YOU GUYS TO REALLY STOP AND PUT PEOPLE FIRST. PEOPLE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] THE NEXT SPEAKER IS SHYAM GANESHRAM. SHYAM. HE'S IN THE RESTROOM.
GOOD EVENING COUNCIL MEMBERS. I HAVE BEEN FIGHTING AN INTENSE, COMPLEX BATTLE REGARDING THE UNAUTHORIZED USE OF MY PERSONAL COGNITIVE DATA. IT'S BEEN OVER A YEAR AND I'VE CONSISTENTLY SHOWN UP HERE TO VOICE MY CONCERNS.
I'VE REVIEWED SOLUTIONS AND I CONTINUE COMING, STANDING BEFORE YOU EVERY MONTH ASKING THE COUNCIL TO USE ITS COLLECTIVE VOICE TO PUSH AND BRIDGE THE GAP TO THE FEDERAL LEVEL, BECAUSE I NEED SENATOR TED CRUZ AND OUR CONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATIVES TO TAKE ACTION THAT THEY ALREADY KNOW IS REQUIRED.
MY FOCUS HAS BEEN ON TO ADDRESS LEGISLATION THAT SURROUNDS THIS AS BECAUSE THERE IS NO PRECEDENT OF THE INTEGRATION OF BIOTECHNOLOGY WITH ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE. IT PROFESSIONALS HAVE CONFIRMED AND VERIFIED THESE FACTS, AND IF I WERE A BETTING PERSON, I WOULDN'T BET AGAINST THEM. I SPENT 30 YEARS IN THAT PROFESSION AND THEY THEMSELVES ARE CONCERNED DUE TO THE LACK OF CLEAR LEGAL DIRECTION, I AM IN AN EXTREMELY VULNERABLE POSITION WITH PEOPLE BELIEVING THAT THEY HAVE ACTUAL RIGHTS TO MY VERY PERSON.
IT'S INEXPLICABLE. THERE ARE TIMES WHEN WE NEED TO SPEAK UP AND MAKE A DIFFERENCE.
AND I BELIEVE THIS IS ONE OF THOSE TIMES. IT'S NOT TIME TO SIT BACK BECAUSE AGAIN, IT'S GOING TO AFFECT NOT ONLY ME AND A COUPLE OF WEEKS OR A WEEK OR SO, WE WILL CELEBRATE THE 250TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.
WE JUST CELEBRATED JUNETEENTH. AND WE'RE VENTURING INTO A DANGEROUS ERA IF WE AS A COUNTRY LOSE THE RIGHTS TO CLAIM OURSELVES AND OUR MINDS AS OUR OWN. SO TONIGHT, LET ME APPEAL TO YOU IN A WAY THAT YOU CAN RELATE TO.
I AM EMBARKING ON A BUSINESS VENTURE THAT INVOLVES MANY PEOPLE THAT MAKE UP THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY TO PROVIDE SERVICES TO LAUNCH THIS BUSINESS. WHAT ABOUT THE PRIVACY OF OUR CONTRACTS? WHAT ABOUT US ESTABLISHING NDAS? THAT'S ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE FROM THE POSITION THAT I'M IN.
SO I JUST WANTED TO BRING THAT TO YOUR CONSIDERATION.
THANK YOU SO MUCH. THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] SHYAM.
GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS SHYAM SUNDER GANESHRAM, AND I AM A RESIDENT OF FRISCO, POSTAL CODE 75035.
I'M HERE TODAY TO STATE THAT NONE OF US WANT A DATA CENTERS FOR A COUPLE OF REASONS.
FIRST, OUR UTILITY BILLS WOULD INCREASE. SECOND, EVEN WITH EQUIPMENT TO REDUCE NOISE AND VIBRATIONS FROM THESE DATA CENTERS, THEY STILL CAUSE NOISE PROOF WINDOWS TO VIBRATE AND STILL MAKE ENORMOUS AMOUNTS OF NOISE POLLUTION, AS WE'VE SEEN IN LOUDOUN COUNTY, VIRGINIA. LASTLY, APPROVAL FOR A DATA CENTERS ARE VERY LOW.
63% OF REPUBLICANS ARE AGAINST AI DATA CENTERS.
INDEPENDENTS ARE 74% AGAINST AI DATA CENTERS, AND DEMOCRATS ARE 75% AGAINST AI DATA CENTERS, SHOWING THAT THIS IS BECOMING LESS AND LESS OF A BIPARTISAN ISSUE.
SO FOR THE GOOD OF YOURSELF AND YOUR RESIDENTS, PLEASE OPPOSE THESE.
AND BY THE WAY, MY SOURCE FOR THIS INFORMATION IS GALLUP.
THANK YOU. I YIELD MY TIME. [APPLAUSE] BRIAN SCANLON.
[00:50:01]
GOOD EVENING EVERYONE. THANKS FOR LETTING ME SPEAK.THAT WAS A CRAZY STORM WE HAD LAST WEEK. USUALLY STORMS DON'T WAKE ME UP, BUT THAT ONE DID.
HOW, DATA CENTERS. THEY PUT A STRAIN ON OUR ALREADY WEAK ENERGY GRID.
THEY'RE APPEARING EVERYWHERE, ESPECIALLY HERE IN PLANO, AND THERE ARE MORE COMING.
HOW, WATER AND ELECTRICITY BILLS HAVE GONE UP.
STATISTICALLY, THEY GO UP MUCH MORE WHEN DATA CENTERS GO UP IN THE AREA, ESPECIALLY IN HOT CLIMATES, WHICH I'M SURE WE ALL KNOW IT'S VERY HOT HERE.
THEY'RE ALSO SUBSIDIZING THESE DATA CENTERS WITH TAX DOLLARS THAT THIS VERY COUNCIL MINUS SHUN WERE WHINING ABOUT SPENDING ON DART, AND THEY'RE USING THAT TAX MONEY TO LEARN THESE BILLIONAIRE COMPANIES TO CONSTRUCT THESE DATA CENTERS.
PLANO RESIDENTS ARE LITERALLY PAYING FOR THESE DATA CENTERS AND HOW MANY JOBS? A COUPLE OF ENGINEERS AND SOME SECURITY. PLEASE START A DATA CENTER MORATORIUM, PLEASE.
AND IF Y'ALL PASS A MORATORIUM. HECK, I'LL EVEN POP A CHAMPAGNE BOTTLE WITH Y'ALL.
KIND OF LIKE Y'ALL DID WITH THE DATA CENTER PEOPLE. THANK YOU.
APPRECIATE IT. [APPLAUSE] MICHAEL TAHINA.
HELLO MY NAME. GOOD EVENING, MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS.
MY NAME IS MICHAEL TAHINA. I AM A PLANO RESIDENT.
I'M HERE TONIGHT ASKING TO ADOPT A TEMPORARY MORATORIUM ON NEW DATA CENTERS APPROVALS.
THIS ISN'T ABOUT BEING AGAINST TECHNOLOGY. PLANO HAS ALWAYS BEEN A LEADER IN INNOVATION.
IT'S ABOUT MAKING SURE GROWTH HAPPENS RESPONSIBLY AND WITH COMMUNITY INPUT AT THE TABLE.
WHETHER SOMEONE SUPPORTS OR OPPOSES THE PROCESS, WE SHOULD ALL AGREE THAT DEVELOPMENTS WITH SIGNIFICANT COMMUNITY IMPACT DESERVES TRANSPARENCY AND PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT. ACROSS THE COUNTY OR ACROSS THE COUNTRY, CITIES AND COUNTIES ARE SLOWING DOWN AND TO STUDY PROJECTS BEFORE APPROVAL. EVEN HERE IN TEXAS, COMMUNITIES SUCH AS HARLINGEN HAVE ADOPTED TEMPORARY MORATORIUMS TO EVALUATE IMPACT OF INFRASTRUCTURE, WATER, ELECTRICITY, AND NEIGHBORHOODS. OTHER LOCAL GOVERNMENTS HAVE REQUIRED ADDITIONAL REVIEW AND PUBLIC NOTIFICATION, RATHER THAN ALLOWING PROJECTS TO MOVE FORWARD WITHOUT CLEAR STANDARDS.
THEY CAN ALSO GENERATE CONSTANT MECHANICAL NOISE FROM THE COOLING EQUIPMENT REQUIRING SIGNIFICANT UTILITY INFRASTRUCTURE AND OTHER PROVIDE RELATIVELY FEW PERMANENT, OH, I'M SORRY, EQUIPMENT REQUIRING SIGNIFICANT UTILITY INFRASTRUCTURE AND OFTEN PROVIDE RELATIVELY FEW PERMANENT JOBS ONCE CONSTRUCTION IS COMPLETE.
20 SECONDS. PLANO CITY IS KNOWN FOR EXCEPTIONAL NEIGHBORHOODS, PARKS, AND SCHOOLS.
BEFORE APPROVING ADDITIONAL PROJECTS OF SCALE, WE JUST WOULD ASK THAT YOU HAVE SOME BASIC QUESTIONS.
WHAT ARE THE IMPACTS OF NEARBY NEIGHBORHOODS? HOW WILL THEY AFFECT THE ELECTRIC INFRASTRUCTURE? WHAT STANDARDS SHOULD EXIST FOR NOISE SETBACKS, LANDSCAPING AND PUBLIC NOTIFICATION, AND HOW DO THESE PROJECTS FIT INTO PLANO'S LONG TERM VISION? LET'S MAKE SURE PLANO REMAINS A CITY THAT VALUES BOTH ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY AND THE PEOPLE WHO CALL IT HOME.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK THAT YOU BEGIN THE PROCESS OF CREATING A MORATORIUM ON DATA CENTERS.
THANK YOU. [APPLAUSE] BILL LYLE.
AT THE END OF LAST MEETING YOU ALL ARE THE END OF THE LAST OF PART TWO.
YOU GOT A COPY OF THIS EMAIL? I'M JUST GOING TO HIGHLIGHT SOMETHING HERE.
BILL SPENT A CONSIDERABLE TIME PUTTING TOGETHER A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF DETAILED INFORMATION. I'VE COMMITTED THIS IS MARK SPEAKING TO LOOKING INTO THE ISSUES FURTHER AND GETTING BACK WITH BILL, AS WELL AS SETTING UP A MEETING WITH STAFF.
THE NEXT MEETING WAS JUST LESS THAN A MONTH LATER.
BUT BEFORE WE GO THERE, LET ME TRY TO HIGHLIGHT KIND OF SOME OF THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THIS.
[00:55:03]
THIS IS A WARRANT, A NOTICE FROM THE PLANO POLICE DEPARTMENT THAT THERE WAS A WARRANT OUT FOR MY ARREST.WHY? BECAUSE THERE WAS A SITE PLAN VIOLATION.
OKAY. $626 BOND WAS DUE AT THAT TIME. SO Y'ALL SHOULD TAKE THIS SERIOUS.
THE POLICE DO. THE CITY OF PLANO DOES. AT LEAST WHEN IT HAS TO DO WITH MY VIOLATIONS.
SO WE WENT FROM MARK'S EMAIL THAT HE WROTE TO COUNCIL, WHERE HE TALKS ABOUT THE SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF DETAILED INFORMATION THAT HE'S GOING TO LOOK INTO. AND THIS THE EMAIL THAT YOU HAVE, THE LAST PIECE OF PAPER YOU HAVE IN YOUR PACKET TONIGHT.
IF WE LOOK AT THE LAST SENTENCE, I INTENDED TO HAVE A HIGHER LEVEL OUTCOME FOCUSED DISCUSSION ON ENFORCEMENT AND RELATIONSHIPS, AS I BELIEVE THAT IS THE MAIN ISSUE. NOTICE HE DIDN'T WANT TO DEAL WITH ANY OF THE DETAILS ANYMORE.
THE DETAILS THAT HE TOLD COUNCIL HE WAS GOING TO LOOK INTO.
HE ALSO SAYS IN THAT EMAIL, HE SAYS THAT HE OWES ME AND STAFF AN APOLOGY.
THE SECOND MEETING WAS REALLY UNPRODUCTIVE IS THE WAY THAT I WOULD DESCRIBE IT.
IT WAS A FAILURE. 20 SECONDS. AND WITH ONLY TWO MINUTES, IT'S REALLY HARD TO GO THROUGH ALL THIS.
BUT I'LL GET BACK TO PART THREE. NEXT TIME WE HAVE PUBLIC COMMENTS.
THANK YOU. SO REGARDING THE SPEAKERS AND SPECIFICALLY TO DATA CENTERS, WE WITH THE CITY UNDERSTAND THE CONCERNS REGARDING THE GROWTH OF DATA CENTERS AS PROJECTS ARE PROPOSED, THE CITY CAREFULLY REVIEWS THEM FOR COMPLIANCE WITH OUR STANDARDS.
WHILE PLANO DOES HAVE DATA CENTERS, THE CITY IS UNLIKELY TO ATTRACT LARGER FUTURE PROJECTS BECAUSE OF THE SIGNIFICANT LAND REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEVELOPMENT. SO RESIDENTS WITH CONCERNS ABOUT BROADER IMPACTS OF DATA CENTERS ON TEXAS'S RESOURCES SHOULD REACH OUT TO THEIR STATE REPRESENTATIVES OR THE PUC COMMISSION DIRECTLY.
THAT BEING SAID, THERE'S NO FURTHER BUSINESS.
WE ARE ADJOURNED.
* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.